A customer in a grey shirt shaking hands with a mechanic in blue coveralls inside a garage

·

The first hundred days of marketing after an acquisition

Someone who buys a thirty-year-old business through a search fund inherits a company that works, and a customer base that mostly knows it through one person. The seller answered the phone, remembered the customers’ histories, and in many cases was the reason they stayed. That relationship doesn’t transfer on closing day, and the new owner usually knows it, which is why the months after a deal tend to produce either too much marketing or none at all.

The scale of this is large. McKinsey’s Institute for Economic Mobility estimates that about six million small and mid-sized businesses face ownership transitions by 2035 as their owners retire, with more than a million of them viable for sale and together worth up to five trillion dollars (McKinsey). Search funds are one route through that transition, and historically they have acquired a business 58 percent of the time (Stanford GSB). Many sellers aren’t ready to hand over what they built. The Exit Planning Institute found that only 13 percent of owners have a formal exit plan, and only 37 percent of boomer owners are very confident their management team could take over (EPI).

The case for changing very little

The standard advice to new owners is to hold still. Coley Andrews, a Stanford lecturer and search fund investor, has told new search fund CEOs to spend their first year listening and learning before setting strategy (Stanford GSB), and Tuck’s long-standing note on search funds advises learning the business and building relationships with employees, customers and suppliers before changing how it runs (Tuck). For operations, that’s sound. Marketing is harder, because a few things can’t wait for month twelve.

What can’t wait

Customers notice an ownership change faster than buyers expect, and silence reads as a bad sign. There’s very little data on customer loss after small business sales specifically, but the closest analogy is instructive: Gallup found that customers of acquired banks left at about 8 percent a year, against roughly 5 percent across the industry, and at 10 percent when the acquirer engaged them less well than the bank it bought (Gallup). The exact figure matters less than what it points to. The relationship the old owner held is now unowned, and someone has to pick it up on purpose.

In the first weeks, that starts with a personal note to the customers who matter most, from the new owner and ideally alongside the old one, saying what is changing and what isn’t. It continues with an inventory of where the business lives online: the website, the Google Business Profile, directory and review listings, and the email domain and accounts the seller used, any of which may be tied to a personal address that leaves with them. I’ve written about a prospect who learned mid-conversation that he had an Avvo listing he didn’t know about; businesses that change hands tend to have more of those. And it means finding out where customers come from now, which the seller often knows by instinct and nobody has written down.

What should wait

Rebranding is the change new owners most often want to make early, and usually the one to hold. The name, the phone number and the way the business answers it carry more of the customer relationship than they appear to. A new website can come later, once the owner knows which pages customers use. Paid campaigns can wait until there’s a way to see what they produce, which in a business that ran on relationships usually means setting up basic tracking first.

The harder transfer

The difficult part is that the seller’s marketing was mostly the seller. Referrals came from people who trusted them, and that trust isn’t listed in the purchase agreement. The real work of the first hundred days is turning some of that personal trust into something the business holds on its own: a record of who the customers are, and a way of reaching them that doesn’t depend on one person’s phone. It’s slow, and it rarely shows up in the first year’s numbers.

Search fund buyers are trained to measure what they’re buying, from revenue durability to customer concentration to the owner’s role in daily operations. The relationship that brought the customers in is harder to put in a model, and it may be the asset most at risk in the first hundred days. Whether anyone on the new team is responsible for it, by name, seems worth settling before closing rather than after.

Sound familiar?

If it does, a short conversation is usually the fastest way to tell whether there’s a fit.

More essays →